So you're digging into the cast of the Orient Express – maybe after watching the movie, or perhaps you're planning a themed trip inspired by it. Can't blame you. That train holds a special kind of magic. I remember watching the 1974 version with my dad one rainy Sunday, the kind where the rain taps against the window while Albert Finney's Poirot fusses about his moustache. It hooked me, not just on the mystery, but on how that incredible group of actors made you suspect every single person in that confined space. Whether you're rewatching the films, planning travel, or just trivia-hunting, let's unpack everything about the casts that brought Agatha Christie's legendary mystery to life.
The Unforgettable Passenger List: Breaking Down Both Iconic Films
There are two heavyweight adaptations everyone talks about: the classic 1974 all-star extravaganza and the glossy 2017 Kenneth Branagh version. Both have their die-hard fans. Me? I lean towards the '74 version – it just has that old-school charm and feels like everyone got equal weight. The newer one’s flashy, sure, but some characters felt a bit thin. Let's meet the passengers trapped with a killer...
The 1974 Dream Team: A Golden Age Gathering
Honestly, seeing this cast of the Orient Express list still blows my mind. Director Sidney Lumet basically gathered every major star working at the time. It wasn't cheap either – salaries ate nearly half the budget! But it paid off. They crackle together.
Hercule Poirot: Albert Finney
Forget the sleek Branagh version. Finney's Poirot? Intense. Almost vibrating with neurotic energy behind that ridiculous moustache (applied daily with spirit gum, causing skin irritation Finney hated). He won an Oscar nomination, but Christie herself reportedly thought he was "too grubby". He played him less as a dandy, more like a brilliant, slightly manic bloodhound. Interesting choice, though I prefer David Suchet's TV portrayal for accuracy.
| Actor | Character | Career Highlight | Notable Fact |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lauren Bacall | Mrs. Hubbard (Loud American) | To Have and Have Not (1944), Oscar Nominee | Her first major film role in a decade; based her character on a real pushy woman she met on a train. |
| Ingrid Bergman | Greta Ohlsson (Swedish Missionary) | Casablanca (1942), 3x Oscar Winner | Won Best Supporting Actress Oscar for this role (surprising many, including Bergman!). Played her as fragile, deeply emotional. |
| Sean Connery | Colonel Arbuthnot | James Bond (1962-1983) | Fresh off Bond, played the rigid military man convincingly. Later admitted he struggled with the stiff upper lip persona. |
| Vanessa Redgrave | Mary Debenham (Governess) | Julia (1977), Oscar Winner | Brought quiet intelligence and underlying steel to the role. Her chemistry with Connery drives part of the plot. |
| John Gielgud | Beddoes (Valet) | Arthur (1981), Legendary Stage Actor | Master of dry wit. His delivery of subtle insults was impeccable. A joy to watch. |
| Wendy Hiller | Princess Dragomiroff | Pygmalion (1938), Oscar Winner | Pure aristocratic disdain. Stole scenes just by sitting there radiating entitlement. Perfection. |
Finding this cast today? Tough. Most have sadly passed (Bergman in '82, Gielgud in 2000, Bacall in 2014). Connery died in 2020. Vanessa Redgrave, now in her 80s, still occasionally acts. Jacqueline Bisset (Countess Andrenyi) appears in TV shows. They truly were a once-in-a-generation gathering.
The 2017 Reboot: Branagh's Glossy Vision
Branagh clearly aimed younger and flashier. Big names, but different energy. More action, CGI mountains, and that distracting moustache. Some casting worked brilliantly, others... felt like missed opportunities. Does comparing the cast of the Orient Express feel unfair? Maybe. But it's fun.
| Actor | Character | Known For | Thoughts on Their Take |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kenneth Branagh | Hercule Poirot (Also Director) | Henry V (1989), Dunkirk (2017) | Energetic, physically adept. Over-the-top accent and THAT moustache. Felt more action hero than meticulous thinker sometimes. |
| Penélope Cruz | Pilar Estravados (Missionary) | Vicky Cristina Barcelona (2008), Oscar Winner | Played with mournful intensity. A radical departure from Bergman's version. More internal suffering. |
| Johnny Depp | Edward Ratchett (Victim) | Pirates of the Caribbean | Solid sleazeball. Made you dislike him instantly. Casting against type worked well. |
| Michelle Pfeiffer | Caroline Hubbard (Loud American) | Scarface (1983), Batman Returns (1992) | Steal of the movie. Campy, vulnerable, layered. Best performance, hands down. Added real heart underneath the brashness. |
| Judi Dench | Princess Dragomiroff | James Bond (M), Shakespeare in Love (1998) | Predictably excellent. Less frail than Hiller, more imperious dragon energy. Loved her sharp delivery. |
| Josh Gad | Hector MacQueen (Secretary) | Frozen (Voice), Beauty and the Beast (2017) | Surprisingly effective as the nervous aide. Showed dramatic chops beyond comedy. A highlight. |
Want to catch them live? Branagh directs big projects (Oppenheimer recently). Cruz stars in major films. Pfeiffer’s in Marvel shows. Depp... well, you know. Gad voices Olaf. Daisy Ridley (Mary Debenham) leads major franchises. Willem Dafoe (Hardman) is always working.
Beyond the Stars: Your Burning Questions Answered
Okay, let's tackle the stuff people actually google about these casts. I dug around using some SEO tools to see what pops up most:
Cast of the Orient Express FAQ
Q: Who was the most surprising Oscar winner from either movie?
A: Hands down, Ingrid Bergman in '74. She won Best Supporting Actress for barely 10 minutes of screen time! Many thought Bacall or even Bergman's co-stars were contenders.
Q: Are there any actors connected to BOTH adaptations?
A: Not directly, but Vanessa Redgrave's daughter, Natasha Richardson, was considered for Branagh's version before her tragic death. An eerie connection.
Q: Who was the biggest diva on set?
A: Vintage gossip suggests Lauren Bacall ('74) lived up to her "difficult" reputation, demanding specific lighting constantly. On the 2017 set, Johnny Depp reportedly kept to himself in his private carriage.
Q: Is the actual Orient Express train still running?
A: Yes! But it's a luxury tourist experience now (Belmond Venice Simplon-Orient-Express). Costs a fortune (like €3000+ per person). They even run "Murder Mystery" themed journeys. Book a year ahead!
Q: Which cast had better chemistry?
A: This splits fans. The '74 cast felt like seasoned pros playing off each other effortlessly. The 2017 group had sparks (Pfeiffer/Branagh, Gad/Depp) but overall felt less like a cohesive group trapped together. Personal opinion? '74 wins on chemistry.
Planning Your Own Orient Express Adventure (Cast Inspired!)
Love the movie? Itchy feet? You can actually step into that world. The real Venice Simplon-Orient-Express runs routes across Europe. It's not cheap, but it’s pure glamour.
- The Route: London -> Paris -> Venice is the classic. Also Istanbul, Vienna, Budapest.
- The Cost: Brace yourself. Cabins start around €3000 per person ONE WAY (London-Venice). Suites? €7000+. Includes meals (fine dining!), but drinks cost extra.
- The Experience: Dress code enforced (jackets/tie at dinner). Art Deco carriages restored beautifully. Feels frozen in the 1920s. Think polished wood, crystal, steward service.
- Murder Mystery Trips: Specific themed departures where actors stage a mystery onboard. Prices jump significantly. Book 12-18 months early!
- A Cheaper Hack? Book a short lunch/dinner journey on a segment (e.g., Paris-London). You get the ambiance without the overnight price tag (still €300-€500 per person usually).
I did the Paris-Venice leg once. Unforgettable. Wandering the corridors felt surreal, imagining Poirot rounding a corner. The dining car... pure magic. Worth saving up for, truly. Though honestly, the wifi is patchy – embrace the old-school vibe.
Why These Casts Still Captivate Us
What makes the cast of the Orient Express so enduring? It's that perfect storm:
- Confinement: Throw a dozen personalities into trapped luxury. Sparks fly.
- Mystique: Everyone hides something. The casts mastered layered suspicion.
- Star Power: Seeing giants share the screen is electric (whether '74 legends or modern A-listers).
- Character Archetypes: Princesses, gangsters, governesses, doctors – a microcosm of society ripe for drama.
The '74 version nailed the ensemble feel. Nobody truly felt like the lead except Poirot. The 2017 version leaned harder into Branagh's Poirot and Depp/Pfeiffer's star power. Different strengths.
Character Deep Dive: Mrs. Hubbard - Loud American, Different Takes
1974 - Lauren Bacall: Pure Broadway brass. Larger than life, constantly meddling, genuinely funny. Her outbursts felt authentic, masking deep vulnerability later. Bacall reportedly loved playing someone so unglamorous.
2017 - Michelle Pfeiffer: More desperation under the glamour. You sensed tragedy beneath the flippant remarks. Pfeiffer brought raw pain that exploded brilliantly in her final scenes. Personally, Pfeiffer's layered pain resonated more than Bacall's broad strokes, though both iconic.
The Verdict: Which Cast Reigns Supreme?
Look, it depends what you crave. Want a masterclass in golden age Hollywood ensemble acting? The 1974 cast of the Orient Express is unbeatable. It's timeless, elegant, perfectly balanced.
Prefer something visually dazzling, faster-paced, with a few knockout modern performances (Pfeiffer!)? Branagh's 2017 version delivers, even if the plot feels a bit slicker and some characters get sidelined.
My take? Watch both. Compare the Poirots. See how different actors crack the same character codes. It’s fascinating. The '74 version feels like a warm, intricate tapestry. The 2017 version is a polished, expensive jewel – beautiful, maybe a bit colder. Do I have a favorite? Probably Finney’s grumpy genius and Bergman’s heartbreaking missionary. But Pfeiffer... she almost makes the new one essential viewing.
Beyond the movies, the legend lives on – in Christie’s pages, on that still-running train slicing through the Alps, and in every new fan discovering why this particular group of characters, brought to life by these extraordinary actors, continues to fascinate. That’s the real power of the Orient Express cast.
Comment