I first heard about the Broken Arrow killings from my neighbor Helen, who lived in Tulsa back in '95. We were having coffee when she suddenly got quiet. "You know what changed how I lock my doors?" she said. "Those teenagers next door in Broken Arrow." Her hands shook a little when she poured more coffee. That conversation stuck with me, partly because I grew up thinking Oklahoma towns were safe. Boy, was I wrong.
What Were the Broken Arrow Killings?
The Broken Arrow killings refer to the brutal murders of Bill and Patsy Smith on February 22, 1995. They were an ordinary retired couple in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma – the kind who waved at neighbors and kept their lawn neat. Their killers? Two local teens they'd known since elementary school. That's what chills me most. The monsters weren't strangers hiding in the bushes. They were kids who'd washed the Smiths' car the summer before.
Core Facts About the Case
- Date: February 22, 1995 (around 8:30 PM)
- Location: Smith residence, 14732 E. 102nd St, Broken Arrow, OK
- Victims: William "Bill" Smith (67) and Patricia "Patsy" Smith (65)
- Perpetrators: Jeremy Jones (16) and Chad Dorsey (17)
- Weapons: Baseball bat, kitchen knives
- Motive: Robbery ($37 stolen)
How the Horror Unfolded
Let me walk you through that night minute by minute, based on court transcripts and police reports I dug up at Tulsa County Courthouse last year. Reading those files gave me nightmares for weeks.
The Attack Sequence
| Time | Event | Evidence Found Later |
|---|---|---|
| 8:15 PM | Jeremy & Chad knock on door, ask to use phone | Neighbor's security light captured them approaching |
| 8:20 PM | Bill Smith beaten with bat in living room | Blood spatter on recliner, shattered vase |
| 8:25 PM | Patsy attacked in kitchen while calling 911 | Unfinished 911 call recording, knife block disturbance |
| 8:30 PM | Teens ransack bedroom for valuables | Drawers dumped, jewelry box emptied |
| 8:40 PM | Perpetrators flee through back yard | Footprints in flower bed, dropped candy wrapper |
The 911 tape... Jesus. You can hear Patsy whispering "Please God" before the line goes dead. Cops arrived in four minutes but it was too late. What gets me is how normal the house looked from the street. No broken windows. Just porch lights on like always.
Victim Profile: Bill & Patsy Smith
Background: Married 42 years. Bill was a retired postal worker, Patsy taught piano lessons. No children.
Community Role: Volunteered at Broken Arrow Food Bank every Thursday. Organized neighborhood watch after a 1992 burglary.
Last Day: Attended church pancake breakfast. Bought groceries at Reasor's. Bill watered roses at 7 PM.
Investigation Breakthroughs and Mistakes
Broken Arrow PD botched the first 48 hours badly. They initially treated it as a burglary gone wrong. Missed crucial evidence:
- Jeremy's bloody shoeprint near the back fence (covered by leaves)
- Chad's fingerprint on the disconnected phone receiver
- Convenience store camera showing them buying gloves earlier
What cracked the case? Jeremy's big mouth. Three days later, he bragged to classmates at Broken Arrow High about "scaring some old folks." A teacher overheard and called police. When detectives searched his locker, they found Patsy's wedding ring stuffed in a gum wrapper.
Legal Timeline After the Breakthrough
| Date | Event | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Mar 1, 1995 | Teens arrested during math class | No resistance; Jeremy asked if he'd miss basketball practice |
| Jun 1995 | Chad accepts plea deal | Life without parole (testified against Jeremy) |
| Nov 1995 | Jeremy's trial begins | Defense claims "video game intoxication" |
| Dec 12, 1995 | Verdict reached | Guilty on all counts; death penalty recommendation |
| 2011 | Chad's appeal denied | Oklahoma Supreme Court upholds sentence |
During sentencing, the judge said something I'll never forget: "This wasn't a crime of poverty or desperation. It was entertainment." Chilling.
Why This Case Changed Everything
Before the Broken Arrow killings, we assumed teen violence meant gang stuff in big cities. These were honor roll students from good families. Shook the whole state.
Lasting Impacts
- Legal Changes: Oklahoma passed "Smith Laws" (1997) allowing 16+ year-olds to be tried as adults for violent crimes
- School Policies: Broken Arrow schools implemented mandatory counseling after weapons were found in 12 lockers within a month
- Community Trauma: Neighborhood watch participation tripled; home security sales spiked 400% in Tulsa County
- Cold Case Reopened: 2003 review linked Jeremy to three unsolved convenience store robberies using DNA
I interviewed Dr. Ellen Voss, a criminal psychologist who consulted on the case. Her take? "The Broken Arrow murders showed us evil doesn't have a profile. These boys had loving parents, no abuse history. That terrifies people more than any serial killer."
Safety Lessons We Ignore At Our Peril
After studying the Broken Arrow killings, here's what I've changed at my own home:
Don't assume you know people. The Smiths recognized those boys. Still opened the door after dark.
Upgrade old locks. Their deadbolt was from 1978. Cops said a credit card could've popped it.
Have an emergency code. If Patsy could've texted "RED" to a neighbor instead of calling 911...
Broken Arrow PD now offers free security audits. Took my sister last month. The officer showed us how Jeremy and Chad exploited:
- Overgrown shrubs near windows (hiding spots)
- Mail pile-up (sign of vacation)
- Garage code written on sprinkler box (!)
Unanswered Questions That Keep Me Up
Even now, decades later, some things don't add up:
- Why take only $37? Patsy's purse had $200 hidden in a tampon wrapper
- Third set of footprints? Crime scene photos show prints too big for either teen
- The missing photo album: Only item stolen besides cash. Family said it contained embarrassing pictures of a local politician
Former detective Marty Ross (who worked the case) told me over beers: "We knew Jeremy didn't plan this alone. But without evidence..." He still carries Patsy's 911 recording on his phone. "My penance," he calls it.
What Survivors Want You To Know
I met Bill's sister Marjorie at a victims' rights event. Tiny woman, steel grip. "People call it the 'Broken Arrow killings' like it's some TV show," she said. "Bill loved rebuilding radios. Patsy collected teapots. Say their names."
Her practical advice for families:
- Document everything: Keep appliance serial numbers separate from your home
- Teach kids situational awareness: Not stranger danger – recognize manipulative behavior
- Know your neighbors: The Smiths' paperboy noticed strange bikes that night but shrugged it off
Straight Answers to Ugly Questions
Did the killers show remorse?
Chad cried at sentencing. Jeremy smirked. During his 2018 parole hearing (denied), he said: "They shouldn't have answered the door." Chilling.
Are the houses still there?
The Smith house was demolished in 2001. Empty lot now. Jeremy's childhood home sold for 40% below market value in 2017.
Why "Broken Arrow killings" not "Smith murders"?
Media coined it because the case broke the town's self-image. Local papers avoid the term now at family's request.
Could this happen today?
Security tech helps, but human nature hasn't changed. Broken Arrow had two similar cases since 1995 – both stopped by neighbors calling cops.
My Personal Take After Years of Research
This isn't some true crime entertainment. I've walked that street. Seen the scars on that community. What angers me most? How preventable it was.
Those boys left clues everywhere:
- Jeremy failed psychology after writing "killing feels natural" in an essay
- Chad tried selling Mrs. Smith's brooch to a pawn shop the next day
- Teachers reported their fascination with torture scenes in movies
We need to stop dismissing red flags as "boys being boys." Bill and Patsy paid for that ignorance.
Broken Arrow High finally installed a memorial garden last year. Stone bench with the inscription: "Stay Vigilant, Stay Kind." I think they'd prefer that over flowers.
Comment